Islamorada Resort Collection
|
couple have a glass or wine at the outside bar

Tiki Bar

A Classic Keys Experience

Hop out of the pool and dive into classic Americana at Tiki Bar. Open for lunch and dinner, this breezy poolside favorite is the perfect setting for sipping tropical cocktails paired with tempting bar bites.

Enjoy delectable tacos, island-inspired seafood specialties, and enticing entrées followed by a slice of heaven—real Key Lime Pie beneath swaying palms.

Hours & Contact

Hours of Operation

Lunch

Open Daily | 11: 30 am - 5:00 pm

Dinner

Open Daily | 5:00 pm - 11:00 pm

Contact

Phone | 305-664-0073

Menus

  • Gluten Free
  • Vegetarian
  • Vegan

Lunch

Small Bites

  • Crispy Calamari

    17
    Herb buttermilk battered, artichokes, sweet peppers, citrus caper aioli

  • Chilled Pink Shrimp Cocktail

    22
    Half dozen local peel and eat shrimp, cocktail sauce

  • Burrata Caprese

    16
    Heirloom tomato, fresh mozzarella, cucumber, basil, olive oil, aged balsamic, focaccia croutons

  • Harissa Honey Chicken Wings

    18
    Half dozen jumbo wings, house made tzatziki sauce

  • Tuscan Caesar

    15
    Fresh romaine, anchovy vinaigrette, olives, tomato, focaccia croutons
    • Chicken $8.00
    • Blackened Mahi $10.00
    • Garlic Shrimp $12.00

  • Crushed Avocado

    12
    Fresh tomato salsa, warm tortilla chips
Back to top

Roman Style Flatbreads

  • Fig and Prosciutto

    23
    White sauce, prosciutto, tomato, shaved onion, arugula, olive oil

  • SBLT

    25
    Marinated shrimp, old bay, applewood smoked bacon, arugula, roasted tomato

  • Greek Chicken

    19
    Red sauce, feta cheese, olives, pepperoncini
Back to top

Handhelds

served with housemade potato chips | fries +$3

  • Fresh Catch Po'boy

    24
    Crispy battered local catch, toasted hoagie roll, spicy remoulade, cabbage slaw, tomato, red onion

  • Island Bacon Pineapple Burger

    20
    Two four-ounce angus beef patties, applewood smoked bacon, grilled pineapple, grilled onion, cheddar cheese, brioche bun, teriyaki sauce

  • Herb-Grilled Mahi Gyro

    27
    Toasted naan, roasted tomato, arugula, feta, tzatziki olive oil, lemon

  • Italian Club

    19
    Prosciutto, shaved ham, genoa salami, burrata cheese, rosemary focaccia, basil, tomato, olive, and artichokes

  • Lobster Tacos

    34
    Lobster meat, cabbage slaw, avocado, local citrus, remoulade
Back to top

Bowls

substitute any protein for crispy cauliflower

  • Hummus Bowl

    16
    Traditional chickpea hummus, edamame, marinated tomato, olive and cucumber salad, warmed naan

  • Blackened Mahi Bowl

    24
    Roasted corn salsa, cilantro rice, marinated cabbage, guacamole, lemon caper sauce, tortilla chips

  • Mediterranean Chicken Bowl

    20
    Marinated chicken breast, romaine lettuce, hummus kalamata olives, tomato, red onion, cucumber, feta vinaigrette, naan bread

  • Garlic Shrimp Bowl

    22
    Citrus marinated shrimp, cilantro rice, cucumber tzatziki sauce, shaved cabbage, fresh vegetable salad, naan

  • Ahi Tuna Bowl

    23
    Sesame seaweed salad, cilantro rice, cucumber edamame, avocado, toasted sesame seed, wonton strips, teriyaki ponzu, spicy aioli
Back to top

Dessert

  • Chocolate Marquis

    12

  • Key Lime Pie

    13
Back to top

White

  • Sparkling, La Marca Prosecco, Italy

  • Rose, Daou, Paso Robles, California

  • Chardonnay, Franciscan Estate, California

  • Sauvignon Blanc, Charlotte's Home, California

  • Pinot Grigio, Ruffino Lumina, Italy

Back to top

Red

  • Pinot Noir, Sea Sun by Caymus, California

  • Cabernet, Bonanza by Caymus, California

  • Merlot, St. Francis, California

Back to top

Beer & Seltzer

Domestic

$6

  • Bud Light

  • Michelob Ultra

  • Voodoo Ranger Juicy Haze IPA

Back to top

Imported

$7

  • Corona Light

  • Heineken

  • Stella Artois

Back to top

Draft

$8

  • Blue Moon

  • Samuel Adams Seasonal

  • Modelo

  • Crazy Lady Blonde Ale

  • FKBC Sun Session IPA

  • FKBC Iguana Bait Hibiscus Kölsch

  • Islamorada Brewing Channel Marker IPA

Back to top

Seltzers

$8

  • Truly

  • Ketel One Peach & Orange

  • Ketel One Cucumber & Mint

Back to top

Zero-Proof Cocktails

$9

  • Virgin Margarita

    Ritual tequila alternative, lime juice, agave nectar, salt rim

  • Virgin Mojito

    Ritual rum alternative, soda water, fresh mint

  • Virgin Cosmopolitan

    Ritual gin alternative, lime juice, cranberry juice, orange juice, simple syrup
Back to top

Keys Cocktails

  • Classic Rum Runner

    14
    Bacardi superior, bacardi black, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, orange, pineapple, grenadine, lime

  • Frozen Tropical Breeze

    14
    Mango, strawberry purée, passion fruit purée, blended with rumhaven coconut

  • Islamorada Colada

    14
    Cruzan rum, cream of coconut, pineapple

  • Tai'd to the Dock

    18
    Appleton reserve rum, diplomático reserva, orgeat syrup, dry curaçao, lime juice

  • Amara Cay Margarita

    22
    Mi campo reposado tequila, solerno orange liqueur, pineapple juice, blue curaçao, lime

  • Summer on the Coast

    14
    New amsterdam vodka, aperol, lemon juice, simple syrup, mint leaves

  • Ocean Eyes

    18
    New amsterdam gin, st~germain, chambord, lime juice, prosecco

  • Hot Chili

    14
    New amsterdam raspberry vodka, triple sec, jalapeños, lime juice, cranberry juice

  • Village of Islands Rita

    22
    Tres generaciones añejo, solerno blood orange liqueur, orange juice, lime

  • Amara Cay Punch

    14
    Bacardi superior, bacardi black, amaretto, orange juice, pineapple juice, grenadine

  • Blueberry Mojito

    15
    Smirnoff blueberry vodka, muddled fresh blueberries, lime, mint leaves, simple syrup, club soda
Back to top

Other

  • Water

    4

  • Redbull & Redbull Sugar Free

    6
Back to top

Dinner

Bites

  • Crispy Calamari

    17
    Herb buttermilk battered, artichokes, sweet peppers, citrus caper aioli

  • Chilled Pink Shrimp Cocktail

    22
    Half dozen local peel and eat shrimp, cocktail sauce

  • Burrata Caprese

    16
    Heirloom tomato, fresh mozzarella, cucumber, basil olive oil, aged balsamic, focaccia croutons

  • Sauteed Mussels

    19
    Bacon, garlic, onion, tomato, white wine butter sauce, herbed crostini

  • SBLT Flatbread

    25
    Marinated shrimp, old bay, applewood smoked bacon arugula, roasted tomato

  • Quattro Formaggio Flatbread

    17
    Mozzarella, reggiano, provolone, pecorino

  • Harissa Honey Chicken Wings

    18
    Half dozen sweet and spicy jumbo wings served with our house made tzatziki sauce

  • Tuscan Caesar

    15
    Fresh romaine, anchovy vinaigrette, olives, tomato, focaccia croutons

  • Ahi Tuna Bowl

    23
    Sesame seaweed salad, cilantro rice, cucumber edamame, avocado, toasted sesame seed, wonton strips, teriyaki ponzu, spicy aioli

  • Mediterranean Chicken Bowl

    20
    Marinated chicken breast, romaine lettuce, hummus kalamata olives, tomato, red onion, cucumber, feta vinaigrette, naan bread

  • Island Bacon Pineapple Burger

    20
    8oz angus beef patty, applewood smoked bacon, grilled pineapple, grilled onion, cheddar cheese, brioche bun, teriyaki sauce
Back to top

Dessert

  • Lemon Shortbread

    12

  • Pistachio Ricotta Cream Cake

    13

  • Chocolate Marquis

    12

  • Key Lime Pie

    13
Back to top

White

  • Sparkling, La Marca Prosecco, Italy

  • Rose, Daou, Paso Robles, California

  • Chardonnay, Franciscan Estate, California

  • Sauvignon Blanc, Charlotte's Home, California

  • Pinot Grigio, Ruffino Lumina, Italy

Back to top

Red

  • Pinot Noir, Sea Sun by Caymus, California

  • Cabernet, Bonanza by Caymus, California

  • Merlot, St. Francis, California

Back to top

White by the Bottle

  • Sparkling, Moet & Chandon, Champagne, France

    160

  • Sparkling, Veuve Clicquot, Champagne, France

    210

  • Rose, Miraval, Cotes de Provence, France

    65

  • Fume Blanc, Ferrari Carano, North Coast, California

    55

  • Sauvignon Blanc, Whitehaven, Marlborough, New Zealand

    50

  • Chardonnay, Boen, California

    55

  • Chardonnay, Cakebread, Carneros, California

    140

  • White blend, E. Guigal, Cotes du Rhone, France

    65
Back to top

Red by the Bottle

  • Cabernet Sauvignon, Daou Reserve, Paso Robles, California

    140

  • Cabernet Sauvignon, Caymus

    265

  • Merlot, Duckhorn, Napa Valley, California

    130

  • Merlot, Educated Guess, Napa Valley

    70

  • Pinot Noir, Belle Glos, California

    125

  • Pinot Noir Paul Hobbs, "Russian River", California

    192

  • Red Blend, Caymus "The Walking Fool", Suisun Valley, California

    60

  • Red Blend, Orin Swift "8 Years In the Dessert", California

    128
Back to top

Beer & Seltzer

Domestic

$6

  • Bud Light

  • Michelob Ultra

  • Voodoo Ranger Juicy Haze IPA

Back to top

Imported

$7

  • Corona Light

  • Heineken

  • Stella Artois

Back to top

Draft

$8

  • Blue Moon

  • Samuel Adams Seasonal

  • Modelo

  • Crazy Lady Blonde Ale

  • FKBC Sun Session IPA

  • FKBC Iguana Bait Hibiscus Kölsch

  • Islamorada Brewing Channel Marker IPA

Back to top

Seltzers

$8

  • Truly

  • Ketel One Peach & Orange

  • Ketel One Cucumber & Mint

Back to top

Other

  • Water

    4

  • Redbull & Redbull Sugar Free

    6
Back to top

Keys Cocktails

  • Classic Rum Runner

    14
    Bacardi superior, bacardi black, blackberry brandy, banana liqueur, orange, pineapple, grenadine, lime

  • Dragon Ball

    14
    New amsterdam gin, midori melon, lime juice, fever-tree elderflower tonic

  • Café Old Fashioned

    21
    Diplomático rum, maker's mark bourbon, coffee liqueur, orange bitters

  • Amara Essences

    17
    Ketel one botanical peach, orange blossom, strawberry pureé, lemon juice, prosseco

  • I Need a Hot One

    19
    Ilegal mezcal, ancho reyes chile liqueur, grand marnier, pineapple juice, lime juice

  • All Eyes on Me

    15
    Pusser's rum, pineapple juice, nonino amaro, lime juice, coco lopez, nutmeg

  • Blueberry Mojito

    15
    Smirnoff blueberry vodka, muddled fresh blueberries, lime, mint leaves, simple syrup, club soda
Back to top

Handcrafted Martinis

  • The 305

    15
    Cruzan guava rum, passion fruit pureé, lime juice, simple syrup

  • Thyme Splash

    15
    Tanqueray no. ten, cucumber, fresh thyme, lime juice, simple syrup, white cranberry juice

  • Amara Sensational

    17
    Islamorada hibiscus gin, st germain liqueur, lemon juice, simple syrup

  • Espresso Martini

    17
    Vanilla vodka, mr black coffee liqueur, baileys, espresso shot
Back to top

Zero-Proof Cocktails

$9

  • Virgin Margarita

    Ritual tequila alternative, lime juice, agave nectar, salt rim

  • Virgin Mojito

    Ritual rum alternative, soda water, fresh mint

  • Virgin Cosmopolitan

    Ritual gin alternative, lime juice, cranberry juice, orange juice, simple syrup
Back to top
Single Platform banner

Main

  • Mac & Cheese

    13
    Elbow macaroni with cheesy sauce

  • Grilled Chicken

    13
    Choice of side

  • Caesar Salad

    11
    Romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing, croutons
    • Add Chicken $4.00

  • Chicken Fingers

    14
    French fries, honey mustard

  • Mini Burger

    15
    American cheese, housemade potato chips
Back to top

Sides

  • Housemade Potato Chips

    6

  • Fruit Cup

    6
Back to top

Desserts

  • Three Housemade Cookies

    8

  • Gelatys Pop

    12

  • Brownie

    7
Back to top

Hydrations

  • Milk

    4
    Whole, 2% or chocolate

  • Fruit Juice

    4
    Apple, pineapple, cranberry, orange or grapefruit

  • Soda

    4
    Coke, diet coke, sprite, ginger ale or pink lemonade
Back to top
Single Platform banner
couple on jetskis

Events Calendar

Authentic island experiences are always on our calendar. See what’s happening at Amara Cay Resort. 

View Events
2 Adults, 0 Children
Book Today